There's a voice in your head that shows up right when you're about to do something that matters. You've probably tried to shut it up. Push it down, drown it out, tell it to sit in the corner while you get on with your life. And somehow it just gets louder.
That's not a coincidence. Your inner critic isn't malfunctioning when you try to silence it and it screams back. That's exactly what it was designed to do.
Dr. Cindy McGovern joined me for episode 452 to talk about why the voices in our heads are so resistant to suppression, where they actually came from, and what it looks like to finally stop letting someone else's old fear run your present life. This conversation hit differently for me because I've been deep in IFS work lately, and so much of what Cindy said mapped directly onto what I've been experiencing in those sessions. That thing where you try to quiet a part of you and it just… gets louder and starts doing destructive things to get your attention? Yeah. We talked about that.
What Happens When You Try to Silence Your Inner Critic
Most of the advice out there tells you to shut the inner critic down. Ignore it. Counter it with affirmations. Tell it to go away.
Cindy's take is different, and it tracks with what I've seen in my own work. These voices don't respond to suppression because they were never meant to be enemies. They're more like backup singers who got too comfortable at the mic. They showed up at some point in your life because they served a purpose — keeping you safe, keeping you small enough to survive the room you were in. The problem is most of them are still singing songs from a completely different era of your life.
Her grandmother's voice is a good example. A woman who grew up in the 1920s had a real and functional rule system for that time. But those rules — about what women should do, who they should be, how much space they should take up — are still echoing in the heads of women a hundred years later. Not because those rules are true. Because no one ever took them off the playlist.
When you try to silence the inner critic without understanding where it came from, you're essentially trying to evict a tenant who thinks they own the place. They just get louder.
How to Figure Out Whose Voice You're Actually Listening To
This is where Cindy introduced what she calls cleaning out your emotional closet. It's less about shutting voices down and more about doing a real inventory of who's actually in there and whether they've earned their spot.
The practice she walked through goes like this. Identify the four most primary voices you interact with on a daily basis. You already know who they are. Then ask two things about each one: Are they positive or negative? And what are you actually getting from keeping them around?
That second question is the one that stings. Because if a voice is consistently negative and you're still listening to it, you're getting something from that arrangement. Maybe it lets you stay in victim mode. Maybe it keeps the story going that you're not ready, not enough, not safe to try. Whatever it is, the voice is serving a function for you even when it's hurting you.
This connects to something Cindy said that I know is going to be uncomfortable for some people to hear. After a certain point, when you've done enough work to understand what's happening and you're still not moving, you've shifted from victim to volunteer. You're choosing to stay in the familiar zone. That's not judgment. It's just honest.
Why Your Inner Critic Sounds Like Your Mother (Or Whoever Raised You)
One of the things this episode made me think about is how much of what we call our inner critic is actually an inherited inner critic. It's not even ours originally.
Primary caregivers get a disproportionate amount of space in our internal world because they were there first. Their voices are some of the loudest because we collected them before we had any ability to evaluate whether we actually wanted to keep them. And then we just… kept them. Assigned them weight. Gave them a microphone.
What Cindy talks about in her book is the gap between being powered and being in-powered. Powered is when you understand something intellectually. You know that your mom's anxiety about emotions isn't the truth about emotions. You can say that out loud. But in-powered is when that understanding has actually moved into your body and changed how you live. That gap can be years wide, and it has nothing to do with intelligence or how much inner work you've done.
I spent a decade doing self-development work and still had worthiness issues that were completely invisible to me because they weren't showing up in my career. They were showing up in my relationships, in what I was tolerating, in the version of love I thought I deserved. I knew better. I wasn't living differently. That's the gap.
Imposter Syndrome Is Not What You Think It Is
Cindy has a take on imposter syndrome that I want to flag because it's genuinely different from what most people say about it.
The standard advice is to silence it, push through it, give it a name and tell it to sit down. Cindy's point is that imposter syndrome only shows up when you're actually growing. It's not a sign that something is wrong. It's a sign that you're at the edge of your comfort zone, which means you're close to something real.
Her reframe is to treat it less like an alarm and more like a signal. If it's showing up, you're probably moving in the right direction. The goal isn't to make it go away. The goal is to keep moving anyway.
This tracks with something I've noticed in my own life. The dark night of the soul moments, the crying-and-hating-everything stretches, those tend to happen right before a real shift. I've gotten to the point where I just expect it. The intensity of the discomfort is usually proportional to how real the change is.
About Dr. Cindy McGovern
Dr. Cindy McGovern is an organizational psychologist, executive coach, and author of The Permission Mission. She's spent her career studying the internal permission gap — why knowing what you want and actually giving yourself permission to go after it are two completely different things. Her work focuses specifically on the inherited voices and outdated rule systems that keep smart, self-aware people stuck.
Find Dr. Cindy's book The Permission Mission and all links at: mindlove.com/452
This Week's Challenge
Take inventory of the four most primary voices in your head — the ones you interact with daily. Write them down. For each one, ask: is this voice positive or negative, and what am I getting from continuing to listen to it? You don't have to do anything with the answers yet. Just see what's actually in there.
Take This Work Deeper
If this episode made you realize you've been carrying around a playlist that isn't yours, that's exactly the kind of thing we work through in the Mind Love Collective. One themed call a month, real people doing the actual work, no overwhelming systems. Just consistent support all year. Join us at mindlove.com/collective.
Listen to Episode 452
Listen on your favorite platform:
Want More Mind Love in your Life?
You know I love to chat….especially with you! Snap a screenshot and tag me @mindlovemelissa and @1stladyofsales on Instagram as you’re listening to this week’s episode. And remember to hashtag #mindlovepodcast, that way I can share your screenshot on my story too!
Subscribe and Review The Mind Love Podcast
Want to stay up-to-date on the latest episodes and strategies? Subscribe in iTunes and you’ll be the first to know when new episodes drop.
If you want to be featured on the show as a reviewer of the week, I’d be super stoked to hear from you. Click here to leave a review.
Share This Episode
