My friends and I have a little bit we do. When one of us gets something the other one wants, a new job or a trip or a kitchen that looks like a magazine, we do a shoulder shake and say “I'm a little jelly.” It takes the edge off. Nobody has to admit anything heavy.
Then I sat down with Stacy Kim and found out I've been using the wrong word for years.
Most of those times, what I was feeling was envy. And the funny thing is that we've made “jelly” cute while envy still feels like something you'd only admit to a therapist. Stacy spent five years researching why we envy our friends, and why that's actually useful information. And she'll tell you she still feels it all the time.
What's the Difference Between Envy and Jealousy?
Stacy explained it so simply that I can't believe nobody told me sooner. Envy is two people. There's you, and there's the person who has something you want.
Jealousy needs three. It's the fear of losing someone to someone else. Your husband looks at another woman. A new coworker starts getting all the attention from your boss that used to go to you. You're afraid of losing a relationship, and there's a third person in the picture.
Once you know which one you're feeling, you can actually do something with it. With jealousy you can ask, am I really about to lose this person? With envy the question is different. What do I want here?
Why Is Envy Considered Bad?
The first thing I asked Stacy was who decided envy was bad. I grew up in religion, fell away from it, and spent years noticing where things had been added or changed along the way to keep people in line. So this part of her research got me.
The very early Christians, the Desert Fathers, kept a list of eight troubling thoughts. Envy wasn't on it. Pope Gregory added it centuries later. And the list was never meant to condemn anyone. It was a way to notice what was going on inside you so you could get closer to God. Over time it turned into the “deadly sins,” and the feeling itself became something to be ashamed of.
Stacy grew up between the US and Korea, and she says other cultures don't carry this baggage. In Korea there are two words for envy. One of them is used for the dark kind, and people rarely say it. The other one people say all the time, and it means something like I envy you, I admire you, I wish I could be like you. Someone gets promoted and their coworkers say it to their face. It's a compliment, and it usually starts a conversation about how they did it.
English just has the one word, and we mostly use it for the ugly kind. No wonder we'd rather say “jelly.”
Why Do I Envy My Friends and Not Celebrities?
This was the part of the conversation that changed how I see envy the most. You only envy people who are close to you.
Stacy's example was a young cellist. She isn't going to envy Yo-Yo Ma. She'll admire him. But she's going to envy the girl in first chair, especially if she's sitting in second. Nobody envies strangers. That sting shows up when what you want feels close enough that you start thinking, why not me?
Back in my early law of attraction days, I learned something similar. If it's showing up this close to you, it might be on its way to you. Stacy came at it from research instead of manifesting, and she landed in almost the same spot. If you envy someone, you're probably closer than you think. And now you have someone to learn from.
What Does It Mean When You Envy Someone's Life?
Stacy calls this the intangible desire. The thing you think you want is usually standing in for a feeling you hope it'll give you.
I envy people who own their homes. We live in a house, but we don't own it. We could, we're just waiting for the perfect one at the perfect time. When I actually looked at what I want from it, though, it's mostly about clutter and space and feeling settled.
Years ago a friend of mine moved from Texas to Orange County, and her first place was a tiny studio. She hated it. I suggested she treat it as a sign to get out and explore her new town, since she didn't want to be home anyway. It changed how she felt about the whole place. I realized I've been doing the same thing with my boys without meaning to. We're out on trails and in the snow constantly, partly because they'd destroy the house in 90 minutes if we stayed in. If I had the most beautiful house in the world, would we be outside as much? I really don't know.
Stacy's point is that once you know the feeling underneath, you can get creative about finding it now. She lives in a New York apartment and envies people with houses, mostly because of her clutter. So she goes to the library.
How Much of What We Want Is Ours?
I asked Stacy how much of what we want we actually picked ourselves. The algorithms seem to know what I want before I do. She said advertisers understand envy a lot better than the rest of us, and the only defense is getting smarter about it ourselves.
She also talked about how wants spread between friends. Research shows that when one person in a friend group gets married or has a baby, others tend to follow. I didn't have my first baby because my little cousin got pregnant. But I'd be lying if I said it didn't nudge me. I was 35, I'd told myself I'd do it by then, and then the world shut down and there was nothing left to wait for.
The want can still be yours. It's worth pausing before you click buy and asking where it came from.
What If the Person You Envy Doesn't Deserve It?
This is the kind I've always had the hardest time with. There are people at the top of my industry, especially in the spiritual world, who got there by cutting corners. I know thinking about them doesn't change my life. And I've still found myself deep in Reddit threads reading the negative reviews, just wanting to know other people see it too.
Stacy says envy is also a moral emotion. It can point at something that really is unfair. Her own envy started as a girl in Korea watching boys get freedoms she didn't have. When the unfairness is bigger than you, she says, stop staring at the person ahead of you. Look at who's next to you and who's a few steps behind, and go forward together.
Then she pushed me a little further. Even with someone you'd never trade places with, ask what part of what they have you'd actually want, and what you'd do with it. I wouldn't trade my integrity for anyone's money or reach. But it's worth knowing what the sting is pointing at, even when the person attached to it is someone I don't respect.
Why Gratitude Isn't Enough
When I told Stacy about my friend's studio and my boys and the trails, she pointed out that the gratitude came after the clarity. Telling someone “don't be envious, just be grateful” skips too many steps. You have to figure out what you want first. Then gratitude has something real to land on.
She also separated guilt from shame in a way I needed to hear. Guilt says I did something that doesn't match who I want to be. Shame says I'm a bad person for feeling this. Shame is what freezes you. You can feel envy all day long and still be a good person. The trouble starts when you decide the envy means something about who you are.
What to Do When You Feel Envy
Stacy's practice is almost too simple. When you feel envy, notice it and name it. Don't push it away and don't decide it makes you bad. Just say, okay, this is envy, and it doesn't feel good.
Then jot it down. She loves index cards for this, and she's right that most of us won't keep a journal. Write down who it was and what you felt. Keep doing that for a while, and the cards start to show you a pattern. In her case, almost all of her envy was about other writers. That's how she finally admitted she wanted to write a book.
I laughed out loud when she brought up index cards. In over 500 episodes nobody has ever mentioned them on the show, and I'd just built a whole index card system at home. I bought every color. It's working.
About Stacy Kim
Stacy S. Kim, PhD, is a coach and former work-family researcher who spent years studying national workforce data before coaching smart, caring women she calls conscientious high achievers. She was born in Seoul and grew up moving between the US and Korea. That gave her two very different ways of seeing envy. Her book is Envy: Why Wanting What They Have Is the Key to Getting What You Want, and every chapter has an index card exercise.
Resources From This Episode
- Stacy Kim's website, where you can connect with her and send her questions
- Envy: Why Wanting What They Have Is the Key to Getting What You Want by Stacy S. Kim, PhD, available wherever books are sold
Listen to This Episode
Watch the full conversation on our YouTube channel. It's still pretty new, so every subscribe really helps it grow.
You can also listen on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
Want More Mind Love in your Life?
You know I love to chat….especially with you! Snap a screenshot and tag me @mindlovemelissa and @stacykim.phd on Instagram as you’re listening to this week’s episode. And remember to hashtag #mindlovepodcast, that way I can share your screenshot on my story too!
Subscribe and Review The Mind Love Podcast
Want to stay up-to-date on the latest episodes and strategies? Subscribe in iTunes and you’ll be the first to know when new episodes drop.
If you want to be featured on the show as a reviewer of the week, I’d be super stoked to hear from you. Click here to leave a review.
Share This Episode